Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?

deviantART

 

Harry Potter and the what? *spoilers ahead?*

Thu Jul 23, 2009, 12:06 PM
  • Mood: Neutral
  • Reading: Love Hina
  • Watching: Stargate SG-1
  • Playing: Runescape
Soooo, I saw it. I have to admit, after what I had heard, I wasn't too thrilled when I stepped into the dark room. But well, I guess I'm a HP nerd who wanted to see it anyway :shrug:
So there.

Low expectations.
Good surprise. :)

It was in my opinion a fair adaptation. Of course, part of me screamed at some... details that were tweaked, some paths that didn't really follow the book storyline, or some characters that behave a bit strangely. But it's an adaptation, right? So why do we care? If I want the book story I'll read the book...

Why I liked it:
- Snape was as good as ever.
- Hermione was cuter than the previous movie, just as every movie (yes, in The Sorcerer's Stone she was better than in The Locked Broom Closet :eager:)
- Beautiful landscapes as always.
- Classes! They ARE in a school! Incredible! :#1: Oh, and even classes that are not their year! :eager: That hasn't happened since movie #1!
- Birds around Hermione. Loved that part in the book, it was pretty nice in the movie. :aww:
- Luna. :la:
- Bellatrix. She left me unimpressed in the previous movie, but she was better actually. :aww:
- Quidditch! :D
- Rupert's love expression is priceless! :lmao:

Why I didn't like it:
- 45 seconds of Tonks? Are you kidding me? :shakefist:
- Once again, Ron is demoted from the heart of the group to the stomach of the group.
- As always, Daniel Radcliffe proves to have the acting skills of a broomstick. EXCEPT when he acts like a moron under the influence of Felix Felicis. I grinned all the way.
- Narcissa. Seriously, what the lol? :o She's supposed to be a beautiful, pale, blonde woman. She lacks the beautiful and half of the blonde part.
- No "DON'T CALL ME COWARD!"? awww :( Plus, "I'm the HBP. kthxbai." And that's all? :| noooo!
- No funeral? lolwhut? :noes:


About other details... Where was Slughorn's big moustache? :( Where is his advanced baldness and his big belly? I don't want a new Fudge-looking guy! :noes:
The battle in Hogwarts? none :(
I don't remember Neville to have Potions in the book. :confused:
Cho was in the movie? :lol: Where? in the crowd at the end? she was credited anyway.
Did the ghoul in the Weasley's attic burn? :noes: And speaking of the Weasleys, I was unconvinced by the twins this time. I tried, but no.
I'm sure I'm forgetting some...



SO... It was a nice way to spend 2h40. I was pretty sure I'd be disappointed, I'm glad I wasn't.



Quote of the day:
"If you don't open the door I'll eviscerate you very slowly until you have nothing left inside you. And you'll still be alive to see that."
Imoen

Devious Comments

love 0 0 joy 0 0 wow 2 2 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconrydi1689:
Overall I liked the movie but I can't help but find the scenes in the movie unconnected, as if they just recorded them and then joined them all together in a messy way, as if they had cut scenes from the book, recorded them with real persons and then pasted into a movie :shrug:.

Also, while you love their actings, I think the only one that stands out is Ron. Hermione LACKED feelings in the birds scene, she was liek "I'm super angry, I'm going to aim my birds at your neck cause you're a bastard!!!! :|" I don't know, she just didn't get to me the way she did in the book.

Also, wtf?? NO FUNERAL? :faint:. I hope they put it in the 7th movie :(

But yeah, I did like the movie and I would watch it again if the cinema wasn't so expensive D:

PS: I love Bellatrix <33 and I think the actress really portrays her magnificiently :love:.
PS2: Yes, Snape for president!

--
Icon by the lovely ^ArtisticAunJuli
Founder of #MasterPhotoshop with =Baz135
Close forum thread
CSS Generator
FAQ
:iconohmgueil:
How would they explain that the wand is in the tomb otherwise? :noes: THEY WOULDN'T DARE PUT IT SOMEWHERE ELSE!... would they? :|

--
#FanArtdA
:iconaglioph0bia:
Your "Didn't like"s were all exactly what I said on the car ride home from the film. :lol:

I completely agree with your reaction. I think it was an enjoyable movie. Pretty faithful, but not 100% exact, to the books. Fun and funny. Missing a few semi-key things. But still good. I'd see it again, even. ;P

--
Torque. It's how I roll.
:iconelvan-lady:
Heh... Oh well.
I would say that you posted spoilers except I've read the book.

--
I am in fact edible.
Well, it could be worse. And it could be better. And IT COULD BE PIZZA!
:iconrydi1689:
I hope that's not a spoiler from the 7th book because otherwise I'll be forced to rip you to pieces :iconwthplz:

No, the argument that you didn't know it won't save you from your death penalty

--
Icon by the lovely ^ArtisticAunJuli
Founder of #MasterPhotoshop with =Baz135
Close forum thread
CSS Generator
FAQ
:iconalicat123:
i agree entirely with your points but also, the actual quality of the film was distracting. it was supposed to be this high definition cinema experience but the whole thing seemed rather fuzzy and undefined at times. I was annoyed at a lot of other things too. overall it was a reasonable film but i seriously hope these last two are amazing, spectacular, incredible and astounding cos if they aren't i will be really jacked off. nice review btw :hug:

--
*PotterShare *PotterShareCaresclick teh linkage! [link] :love:
Random Deviant I read the FAQ
:iconohmgueil:
It's not a spoiler! They want to gather every wand to make a gigantic laser beam to anihilate the Earth and Voldemort with it! :noes:

--
#FanArtdA
:iconohmgueil:
People who haven't should be tortured :shakefish: C'mon, it's 4 years old...

--
#FanArtdA
:iconelvan-lady:
Agreed.
Remember just a few years ago, when pottermania was at its fullest?

--
I am in fact edible.
Well, it could be worse. And it could be better. And IT COULD BE PIZZA!

Journal History

Shoutboard

:|

Shoutbox

~MrBigBusiness:iconMrBigBusiness:
:D
Wed Mar 11, 2009, 4:01 AM
~Duorok:iconDuorok:
bouyah !
Sun Sep 28, 2008, 10:15 PM
~AbbyDarling:iconAbbyDarling:
:love: :love: :love:
Tue Jun 3, 2008, 4:05 AM
~iamsostupid:iconiamsostupid:
<3
Mon May 26, 2008, 9:47 AM
=OhmGueil:iconOhmGueil:
SO I HED U LIEK MUDKIPZ?!?
Tue Apr 29, 2008, 1:28 PM
`catluvr2:iconcatluvr2:
EternalJedi's comment wouldn't have worked anyways, it would have been a Mudkip. :bucktooth:
Mon Apr 14, 2008, 3:51 AM
~EternalJedi:iconEternalJedi:
:noes: oh well :boogie:
Tue Apr 1, 2008, 4:06 PM
~EternalJedi:iconEternalJedi:
:iconpanicatthediscoplz:
Tue Apr 1, 2008, 4:05 PM
~nowiss:iconnowiss:
*bump*
Wed Nov 21, 2007, 11:18 AM
~The-Lauz-Effect:iconThe-Lauz-Effect:
*flomp* :love:
Fri Oct 5, 2007, 3:17 AM
~Sofisofas:iconSofisofas:
:glomp:
Fri Jul 13, 2007, 4:42 PM
~EmpyreanDragonSpirit:iconEmpyreanDragonSpirit:
:glomp:
Thu May 31, 2007, 5:12 AM
*kimurii:iconkimurii:
Non mais il t'as traité de con celui-là :|
Mon May 28, 2007, 1:19 PM
=marvelous-magic:iconmarvelous-magic:
:hug:
Mon Apr 23, 2007, 12:16 AM
~Duorok:iconDuorok:
Kerdytééécon !
Sun Apr 22, 2007, 1:16 PM
~Sofisofas:iconSofisofas:
:glomp:
Wed Apr 4, 2007, 10:13 AM
~laerry:iconlaerry:
love!shout - Hi! :flirty:
Tue Apr 3, 2007, 6:12 PM
*Cat-in-the-mist:iconCat-in-the-mist:
This is *NOT* a shout. This *NEVER* was a shout... (and this was my Nixonian moment :D
Sun Jan 21, 2007, 9:13 AM
~princess88alasse:iconprincess88alasse:
:paranoid: mwahahaha :evillaugh: :hug:
Tue Jan 16, 2007, 10:03 AM
~laerry:iconlaerry:
Bootstrap is the most bestest :hug:
Mon Dec 18, 2006, 7:12 PM

Who pwns and gets the mouse? 

32%
14 deviants said Garfield (got lasagna?)
23%
10 deviants said Crookshanks
9%
4 deviants said Sylvester
9%
4 deviants said Cheshire Cat (creepy, in a good way)
7%
3 deviants said Tom
5%
2 deviants said Solenbaum (never gets enough credit D: )
5%
2 deviants said Felix (magical bag! yay!)
5%
2 deviants said Puss (Madre de Dios!)
5%
2 deviants said Other (did I forget? :noes: comment! (but I got no place left))
2%
1 deviant said Fat Cat (pwned by squirrels :innocent:)

Site Map